April 2012

 

  What's New!

   KDG HR Solutions Newsletter
 

 

Square megaphone man

 

Greetings!

Workplace harassment, conduct issues, and embezzlements can be very costly to an employer. Do not make matters worse by conducting an investigation that is poorly designed, poorly executed, and poorly communicated. Join us for our April Lunch & Learn when Jay Rosenlieb will provide you with the tools you need to conduct a meaningful investigation and the information you need to help you avoid the common mistakes that employers make when investigating employee misconduct. We'll see you then and hope you enjoy this issue of our newsletter.  


Sincerely,

 Robin Paggi, MA, SPHR-CA, CPLP, CPC
 

 Paralegal/HR Professional

 KDG HR Solutions

 rpaggi@kleinlaw.com

 (661) 328-5267

 

 

Training Tip 

Must employers pay employees who seek additional training to enhance their knowledge or skills? The California Labor Commissioner has adopted the federal stance with regard to whether employees must be paid for time spent at training programs.  Essentially, the training program time will not count as compensable hours worked ONLY IF all of the following criteria are met:

  • Attendance is voluntary (meaning that the program is not required, nor is the employee led to believe that the current employment relationship or position will be adversely affected by non-attendance);
  • Attendance is outside of regular working hours;
  • The course is not directly related to the employee's job (that is, the training is not designed to make the employee handle his current job more effectively, as opposed to training for a new job or new skill which would not be considered to be directly related); and
  • The employee does not perform any work during the time of attendance.  

Contact Katy Raytis for more information or if you are interested in a Tuition Forgiveness Agreement for your workplace. 

 

California Prevailing Wage Seminar 
April 12, 2012 

Please join us and Kern County Builder's Exchange on April 12th for our California Prevailing Wage Seminar.

This presentation will provide up-to-date information on California prevailing wage laws and will include a broad overview of employer obligations to ensure compliance.

 

Topics include:

*    recent legislation

*    duties and responsibilities under the law

*    how prevailing wage requirements are enforced

*    tips to avoid liability

In This Issue

Thorough, Well-Documented Investigation Defeats Discrimination Claim

Honesty is the best policy when dealing with HR issues

 

Join Our Mailing List!

 

UPCOMING WORKSHOPS

April 11, 2012 Bakersfield

9-11:00am- AB1825 State-Mandated Sexual Harassment Prevention Training - $50  

April 12, 2012 Bakersfield

10:30-11:30am- California Prevailing Wage Seminar $35 Click Here for More Info

April 18, 2012 Bakersfield

11:45-1pm- LUNCH AND LEARN: Internal Investigations $20   

Click Here for More Info     

 

April 25, 2012 Fresno

11:45-1:00pm- LUNCH AND LEARN Internal Investigations $20
 Click Here for More Info   

 

April 25, 2012 Fresno

2-4:00pm- AB1825 State-Mandated Sexual Harassment Prevention Training - $50  
Click Here for More Info
 

 

         

For more information or to RSVP contact

Kelsey Bonesteel at:

kbonesteel@kleinlaw.com
or call (661) 328-5218. 

 

 ALL SESSIONS REQUIRE PRE-REGISTRATION
Thank You! 

 

 For additional details on each workshop, visit our website at:
www.kdghrsolutions.com

 

   

Like us on Facebook 

     

 

Thorough, Well-Documented Investigation Defeats Discrimination Claim
By Robin Paggi
 

A recent court case demonstrated why well-executed investigations are so important when handling allegations of employee misconduct. Arturo Martinez was a manager for W. W. Grainger, Inc. His manager, Jeff Timm, became concerned about Martinez's management style after having a conversation with some of his subordinates. Timm asked Joyce LePage, who worked in Grainger's HR department, to conduct an investigation into allegations that Martinez was being too harsh with his employees. LePage spoke with a number of employees who reported that Martinez managed "by intimidation and threats" and that he was "brutal and belittling" among other similar negative comments. LePage took extensive notes during the interviews with the employees, and then she and Timm met with Martinez to discuss how to move forward. When Martinez would not acknowledge that there was a problem with his management style, he was fired, and then subsequently sued for racial and national origin discrimination. The trial court dismissed the lawsuit, then Martinez appealed and lost in that court too. According to court documents, Martinez failed to establish that the reason for his termination was because of something other than his performance. Moreover, the court noted that "the deposition testimony of the branch employees confirmed that the notes LePage used to create the summary list for Martinez were accurate and that the specific examples she gave of his (Martinez's) problematic managerial style were brought up during her investigation." Thus, a thorough, well-documented investigation into employee misconduct is one of the best defenses against discrimination lawsuits.

 

Honesty is the best policy when dealing with HR issues
By: Robin Paggi

 "Honesty is the best policy." This quote, attributed to Benjamin Franklin, is especially true when it comes to employment issues. The following employers learned that lesson the hard way.

Bingham Toyota Isuzu learned not to make promises it couldn't keep. Kevin Helmer applied for a position in the parts department at the auto dealership and was interviewed by Bob Clark, the director of parts and service. Helmer told Clark during the interview that he needed to earn at least $5,700 per month. According to court documents, "Clark then opened his desk drawer, pulled out a financial statement, made some calculations, and stated that 'if (Helmer) had been employed by Bingham since January, (he) would have made $70,000 up to that point." So, Helmer left his job at a competing dealership, and proceeded to make less than $5,700 a month at Bingham. Helmer talked to Clark about making less pay than he was promised and was ignored for a while, then was told he could work extra hours to earn the pay, next was asked to prove that he had actually made $5,700 a month at his previous job, and finally was fired. He sued the company and Clark for promissory fraud. The jury awarded Helmer $450,913 in compensatory damages and $1.5 million in punitive damages (later reduced by the Court to $675,000).

 

Texaco learned not to sugarcoat performance evaluations. According to www.leagle.com, employee Emma Vaughn received favorable performance evaluations, merit increases, and no criticism of her work performance before being terminated by Texaco. During the subsequent lawsuit, Texaco management stated that Vaughn was terminated for poor performance, even though its documentation demonstrated otherwise. Managers said that they refrained from confronting Vaughn about her poor performance because she was black. Ironically, "this direct evidence clearly shows that (her supervisor) acted as he did solely because Vaughn is black...Vaughn has, consequently, established that Texaco discriminated against her." She was awarded $465,000 in punitive damages.

 

Michaels Stores, Inc. learned not to make up bogus reasons for firing employees. Store manager Kara Jorud was terminated while she was undergoing chemotherapy for breast cancer. In her subsequent lawsuit, Jorud claimed that district manager Skip Sand began calling her days after her mastectomy asking when she would return to work. When Jorud did return to work, Sand frequently visited the store to criticize her performance. Jorud was then terminated for theft, a charge she later disproved and Sand admitted was false. According to the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, a jury awarded Jorud $8.1 million.

 

The examples above demonstrate that deceit is expensive and just not very smart. Being honest when it comes to employment issues is the right thing to do and is the more intelligent way to go. As Thomas Jefferson said, "Honesty is the first chapter in the book of wisdom."

 

KDG HR Solutions Team  
   

 

                                    
      David Blaine, Esq.,        Jeffrey Noe, Esq.        Katy Raytis, Esq.     Jay Rosenlieb, Esq.
      SPHR
                                       
       Kelsey Bonesteel          Robin Paggi, MA,         Aimee Kircher, Esq.,  Amy L. Hanf, Esq.
       Marketing Assistant     SPHR-CA, CPLP,           SPHR
                                        
CPC, HR Consultant

 

 

 

 

 

 

4550 California Avenue, 2nd Floor                  5260 N. Palm Avenue, Ste. 201

                     Bakersfield, CA 93309                                      Fresno, CA 93704
                        (661) 634-1200                                              (559) 801-0606

Strategic Human Resources.  Employment Law Solutions.
www.kdghrsolutions.com